Twin a thinks they are older than twin b, but twin b thinks they are older than twin a. Correct resolution of the twin paradox michael huemer. Spacetime diagram explanation of the twin paradox the answer to this question is that for the astronaut to return to the earth, heshe must change direction and thereby switch from one inertial frame to another, and that breaks the symmetry between the two observers. The twin paradox scenario results for aa, when b returns to the same clock a.
Diagrams and equations demonstrating the symmetry of clock rate and length measures across inertial frames. This letter discusses the results of a recent study of the twin paradox problem. Pdf it is pointed out that a complete resolution of the twin paradox demands that. The socalled twin paradox is easily resolved by noting that there is a physically meaningful disinction between the experiences of the two twins during the trip. It uses the relativistic doppler effect to demonstrate how the paradox works. The paradox in the twin paradox is that a naive view of the problem would suggest that the situation ought to be perfectly symmetric.
According to the earthling, the returning astronaut. The most famous paradox of all and just some of the analysis weve done in various ways with it and then just the experimental results that show yes, no matter how weird it seems, the twin paradox actually is an experimentally proven fact. This result appears puzzling because each twin sees the other twin as moving, and so, according to an incorrect and naive application of time dilation and. The twin paradox and the principle of relativity oyvind gron oslo university college, faculty of engineering, p. The twin paradox could occur if one person say, one of two twins was in a dramatically different gravitational field than another person the other of the two twins, or if one person moved much faster than another person. The twin paradox is the analogue of our second example with two curves starting and ending at the same points. Relativity trail, free pdf format, with 192 pages, 65 diagrams. Prediction of a new result for the twin paradox experiment, consistent with the. Jan 27, 2017 so twin b thinks that only 210th of a year has elapsed for twin a back home as they return using the same relative time dilation factor of 10. The twin paradox in special and general relativity. Gardner offers lucid explanations of not only the special and general theories of relativity, but of the michelsonmorley experiment, gravity and spacetime, machs principle, the twin paradox, models of the universe, and other topics.
This video is about the famous twin paradox of special relativity, and how time can appear to be faster for two different observers at the same time. One clever solution to this paradox is that es conclusion is right. How does relativity theory resolve the twin paradox. Want exclusive updates whenever a new video is posted. The entire scenario is based on the idea that biff was traveling very fast, so time slowed down for him. One twin travels at great distance at the speed of light and returns, much younger than the other twin. If you dig a little deeper and show a little determination, hopefully youll begin to be more comfortable that einstein really was right. The present paper analyses the twin paradox as presented by van flandern 1 and confirms the results obtained by standard relativistic calculations. The explanation usually given is that since the twin travelling on the rocket experienced accelerations it is not inertial, therefore the earth twin is.
Twin paradox, an apparent anomaly that arises from the treatment of time in germanborn physicist albert einsteins theory of special relativity. Einstein only called it peculiar, while langevin explained the different. However, in the present article i will use the twin paradox as a pedagogical entrance to the general theory of relativity. Relativity simply explained free books epub truepdf azw3 pdf.
What is the proper way to explain the twin paradox. The twin paradox in special relativity and in lorentz. The twin paradox and the principle of relativity arxiv. In other experiments, acceleration doesnt cause asymmetry eg.
A second inertial observer, who is in relative motion. Relativity trail, free pdf format, with 192 pages, 65 diagrams and 75 illustrations, will provide you with complete detailed algebraic. A simple explanation of special relativity and the twin. The opinion of the world famous scientists on the theory of relativity varied greatly. In this case time dilation states that more time will have elapsed on a clock that moves between two points with constant velocity as is required if a is at rest in some lorentz frame than on a clock b that has moved on an accelerated trajectory. The twin paradox in the theory of relativity article pdf available in european journal of physics 274. This theory predicts that if one of a pair of twins were to fly away from the earth all the way to alpha centauri for instance and then fly back again. The twin paradox has a very simple resolution in this framework. The spaceship needs acceleration and deceleration, thus ts conclusion is. How to understand the twin paradox science publishing group. The counterintuitive nature of einsteins ideas makes them difficult to absorb and gives rise to situations that seem unfathomable. Aug 29, 2016 minutephysics host henry reich explained the twin paradox, its solution, and why it is not technically a paradox in a pair of recent episodes.
A similar discussion of the failure of spacetime diagrams. I agree, in the twin paradox class of experiments, twin bs acceleration is the cause of the asymmetry. The crucial concept is the proper time of a moving body. The twin paradox is one of those problems that encase within it a beautiful solution or might i say, answer. Mar, 2018 there is no more famous conundrum in special relativity than the twin paradox. The twin paradox part 4 paradoxes to ponder coursera. An explanation of the twin paradox and why its not.
This mere fact explains why the number of pulses received by the twins is not symmetrical. Because of time dilation, time is running more slowly in the spacecraft as seen by the earthbound twin and the traveling twin will find that the. Paranjape, benoit sirois the twin paradox, which evokes from the the idea that two twins may age differently because of their relative motion, has been studied and explained ever since it was first described in 1906, the year after special relativity was invented. Twin paradox and causality 1 introduction 2 matter of the. Pdf the twin paradox in the theory of relativity researchgate. The twin paradox is the best known thought experiment associated with. The proposed paradox arises because each twin sees the other. The spaceship needs acceleration and deceleration, thus ts conclusion is not right. In order to catch it, it is also appropriate to look for an explanation in the simplest context where the non trivial differential ageing phenomenon is established, that. At the reunion, both twins agree by inspection that she is older. Correct resolution of the twin paradox michael huem er in the following, i explain the twin paradox, which is supposed to be a paradoxical consequence of the special theory of relativity str. The twin paradox, which evokes from the the idea that two twins may age differently because of their relative motion, has been studied and explained ever since it was first described in 1906, the year after special relativity was invented.
A speci c point on a spacetime diagram is called an \event. The majority of them, overwhelmed by mathematical difficulties of the general theory of relativity, decided to keep silent. Philosophy and the twin paradox the philosophy forum. The earthbound twin remains in a single constant velocity reference frame the entire time while the traveling twin must accelerate to turn around and come home. The famous twin paradox of special relativity involves a scenario where one twin he rockets away from the home twin her, coasts to a faraway turnpoint, reverses course, coasts back, and comes to a halt when they are reunited. Lecture notes relativity physics mit opencourseware. Alternative text, and animation of the twin paradox. Hawkings black hole paradox explained fabio pacucci. Aug 25, 2016 one of the most revolutionary concepts that we learned in the 20th century is that time is not a universal measurement. Olavs plass, n0 oslo, norway abstract it is argued that the usual formulation of the twin paradox makes use of the general principle of relativity, i. Contains textual description not found in the document below.
Im trying to wrap my mind around the twin paradox, but i cant figure out this one problem from my textbook. In physics, the twin paradox is a thought experiment in special relativity involving identical twins. Suppose one of two twins carrying a clock departs on a rocket ship from the other twin, an inertial observer, at a certain time, and they rejoin at a later time. The first episode sets up the problem and gives a brief explanation for how time rotates, and the second video fully answers the twin paradox. Mar 17, 2003 paul daviess recent article how to build a time machine has rekindled interest in the twin paradox, arguably the most famous thought experiment in relativity theory. A simple explanation of special relativity and the twin paradox. First chose one specific inertial frame of reference, say the rest frame of the earth which well pretend is inertial. One twin remains on earth while the other twin goes on a highvelocity time trip to visit a distant planet. We live in the most peaceful time in human history. The twin with the greatest average velocity between the events p1 and p2 is youngest when the twins meet at p2. For either twin, in effect, nontrivial differential ageing should manifest itself in. Under the general relativistic formulations explained in 12, eartha ages by.
But it cannot be explained as a result of the doppler effect by the observer in the rocket, since the detector is permanently at rest relative to the emitter in this. Time dilation, in the theory of special relativity, the slowing down of a clock as determined by an observer who is in relative motion with respect to that clock. It doesnt matter how much our lives are governed by the same seconds, minutes, hours, days, and weeks, regardless of where we live on the globe, time will never be absolute. Absolute frame of reference in the physics community. The clarity of the text is especially enhanced by the brilliant. Find materials for this course in the pages linked along the left. Machs principle, the twin paradox, models of the universe, and other topics. The twin paradox is a thought experiment in special relativity, in which the ages of twins are compared after one has made a high speed journey over a long period of time, while the other has remained stationary. Once weve chosen a reference frame, we can define coordinates t,x,y,z for every event that takes.
Pdf the twin paradox and the principle of relativity researchgate. I give the correct resolution of the paradox, explai ning why str is not incon sistent as it app ears at first glanc e. Again there is a paradox, for creative work demands both a passionate interest on the part. A version of this article was first published in fermilab today. The paradox in the twin paradox is that the situation appears symmetrical so each twin should think the other has aged less, which is of course impossible there are a thousand explanations out there for why this doesnt happen, but they all end up saying something vague like its because one twin is accelerating or you need general relativity to understand it. And the above resolution of the twin paradox is contrary to the spirit of the general theory of relativity. According to einsteins theory of relativity, the faster you travel, the slower time passes.
Time, topology and the twin paradox jeanpierre luminet. This would cause them to experience the passage of time. Pdf in the standard formulation of the twin paradox an accelerated twin considers himself as at rest. Keck science center, the claremont colleges a spacetime diagram shows the history of objects moving through space usually in just one dimension. A geometrical view of time dilation and the twin paradox. Aug 26, 2016 last weeks lesson was time dilation, and you hopefully understand the basics of how it works. It is a problem that involves relativistic time dilation, from the special theory of relativity the jargon might seem tough, but the solution is quite intuitive. Embracing the twin paradox is an important first step as you dip your toe into the nonintuitive world of special relativity. The reason is that one of special relativitys conditions is a uniform motion. Spacetime diagram explanation of the twin paradox the answer to this question is that for the astronaut to return to the earth, heshe must change direction and thereby switch from one inertial frame to another, and that breaks the.
Pdf the twin paradox and the principle of relativity. A var iety of the twin paradox with symmetrical causal chains of events is considered, where the motional trajectories. Variations on the twin paradox subhash kak the word paradox comes from latin paradoxum or greek paradoxos, literally contrary to opinion, and it may mean a selfcontradictory statement or one that appears selfcontradictory, when it is actually true. Because of special relativity, although the twins were born at the same time, after the journey their ages are now years apart. Well, no and theyre killing fewer and fewer people, even though the world population is at an alltime high. A new postscript, examining the latest developments in the field, and specially written for this edition, is also included. The ordinary twin paradox is a problem of ageing of two twin observers a and b, b travels with a relativistic speed and returns back to a where a is at rest. Twin paradox the story is that one of a pair of twins leaves on a high speed space journey during which he travels at a large fraction of the speed of light while the other remains on the earth. Embedded youtube animation, with textual description and a little math.
But the ones who could understand relativity welcomed it. Mar 30, 2015 the twin paradox is a thought experiment where one twin stays on earth and the other takes a journey through space at incredibly high speeds before returning home. Relativity simply explained dover classics of science. In physics, the twin paradox is a thought experiment in special relativity involving identical twins, one of whom makes a journey into space in a highspeed rocket and returns home to find that the twin who remained on earth has aged more. Why the twin paradox arises the twin paradox arises in the special theory of relativity sr. Information relativity theory solves the twin paradox symmetrically, physics essays, 29, 304308 2016. It seems evident that acceleration has a role to play, however this role. Motivation also plays an important role in our ability to be creative.
1136 469 769 158 955 1587 1614 399 279 1350 287 753 710 1039 38 720 1408 1018 1612 1231 1245 25 1001 1199 962 1217 839 1257 127 713 1317 1307 788 162 1495